FOLLOW US

Error
  • JUser: :_load: Unable to load user with ID: 62

Swaziland: Court Confirms New Rights for Women

If Swazi women are to realize their rights as enshrined in the Constitution, there needs to be a holistic review of the marriage laws in the country. A good way to start would be amending all marriage laws by passing legislation that will bring about equality of spouses in marriage.

Phakama Shili, advocacy officer at Swaziland’s Media Institute of Southern Africa (MISA-Swaziland), writes a weekly column for the Swazi Observer. The column, ‘Constitutionally Speaking’, considers human rights and the quest for democracy in Swaziland. Read on for this week’s article on the state of marriage in the landlocked kingdom.

Half a loaf is not better than none: Assessing the Swaziland High Court Judgment on marital power (Nombuyiselo Sihlongonyane v Mholi Sihlongonyane High Court Case No. 470/2013 A)

On 18 July 2013, the Swazi High Court passed a judgement declaring marital power unconstitutional.

The concept of marital power denies women married under civil rites and in community of property the ability to sue and being sued in their own name. Much as this judgment has been received with delight by lots of women in Swaziland, the practical implications are depressing: discrimination of women in administering matrimonial property continues to persist.

The case which brought the matter to the fore involved a husband and wife who got married under a civil rites marriage in community of property with the husband retaining the power to administer the matrimonial possessions. The wife made an application to the court to have her husband removed as administrator of the joint property as a result of the husband's alleged mismanagement of the estate.

The Constitutional question arose after the husband challenged his wife's capacity to institute legal proceedings without his assistance. Consequently the High Court had to interrogate sections 20 and 28 (on equality and non-discrimination of women) of the Swaziland Constitution and determine if the common law position of marital power still exist in light of the constitutional dispensation. Under the common law, the property of spouses falls into a common pool which, although jointly owned by the spouses, is entirely controlled by the husband unless the spouses execute an ante-nuptial contract before marriage. This places the wife, in relation to the property of the marriage, in almost the same position as a minor child except the fact that guardianship of a minor serves the interests of the minor, whereas marital power serves the interests of the husband.

Marital power embraces three elements, namely:

a) The husband's power as head of the family by virtue of which he has the decisive say in all matters concerning the common life of the spouses and determines, inter alia where and in what lifestyle they are to live

b) The husband's power over the person of his wife, including her representation in legal proceedings, and

c) The husband's power over the property of the wife which enables him, in his absolute discretion, to deal with the joint estate as its administrator.

The overall effect of the husband's exercise of marital power is to subject the wife to the husband's guardianship, effectively making her subservient to her husband. The court relying on the case of The Attorney General v Mary Joyce Doo Aphane, Civil Appeal case 12/2010 held that marital power unlawfully and arbitrarily subordinates the wife to the power of her husband and was an unfair discrimination based on sex or gender inasmuch as it adversely affects women who have contracted a civil rites marriage in community of property with no ante-nuptial contract. The court further observed that, whilst it is accepted in common law that a married woman who is subject to the marital power may approach the court for leave to sue without the aid of her husband, such notion or concept is discriminatory of such women in so far as it applies to such class of women and not men.

"A married man does not, under any circumstances, have to apply for such leave and therefore this common law requirement constitutes an unfair discrimination", the court noted.

Notwithstanding this observation, the court did not entirely abolish the common law position of marital power. It confined itself to the issue of women's capacity to institute and defend legal proceedings without the assistance of their husbands. Undoubtedly, the root cause of the dispute in this case relates to the husband's inability to exercise marital power to administer the joint estate in good faith. In this case the Applicant approached the court as a result of her husband's maladministration of the matrimonial property in the exercise of such marital power. Thus even if her husband did not challenge her legal capacity, she would have still proceeded under common law to prove that her husband had acted fraudulently in dealing with the joint property to her loss as this will be the case in the main application which will be held at a later stage.

In other words, if marital power is declared unconstitutional, the starting point in making a just and equitable enquiry would be for the court to place the wife on an equal footing as her husband by pronouncing joint administration of the matrimonial property. This therefore means that in order for this kind of marriage to comply with the Constitution, the entire concept of marital power must be abolished. For other women in the same position as the Applicant, their emancipation only extends as far as their capacity to institute and defend legal actions; however, their husbands retain their common law status of being sole administrators of their matrimonial properties (half a loaf is no better than nothing at all).

Recommendations

In order for Swazi women to realize their rights as enshrined in the Constitution, there needs to be a holistic review of the marriage laws in the country. A positive way to start would be amending all marriage laws by passing legislation that will effectively facilitate equality of spouses in marriage.

Similar laws have been passed by several countries in the region. Botswana, for instance, and Namibia abolished marital power by enacting the Abolition of Marital Power Act of 2004 and the Married Persons Equality Act of 1996 respectively, thereby giving equal power to spouses to administer their joint property.

In promoting equality and non-discrimination, as required by the Convention on the Elimination of all forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW) and other regional and international obligations, Swaziland must take action to pass a law that will put to an end the power of husbands to choose the domicile of their wives just like South Africa did by passing the Domicile Act in 1992.

There is also a need for Swazi civil society to collaborate with lawyers in providing refresher courses and discussion forums that will enable them to develop appropriate litigation strategies to ensure the meaningful realization of the Bill of Rights.

A printed version of this article appeared in the Swazi Observer on Thursday August 1, 2013

You will find all of Phakama’s ‘Constitutionally Speaking’ articles on MISA-Swaziland’s by clicking here

Tagged : No tags for this article

Latest Blog

Harry Styles Sends Sister on Holiday

Harry Styles Sends Sister on Holiday

Posted by Adam Monday August 5, 2013HARRY Styles is one generous brother!The One Direction star has paid for his older sister Gemma, 22, to go on the trip of a lifetime as a present for graduating from Sheffield University in the UK with a First-class degree.“Harry is giving Gemma a massive treat for getting a first at Sheffield Uni. He’s...

0 comments

Johnny Depp Looking For Homes in The UK

Johnny Depp Looking For Homes in The UK

Posted by Adam Monday August 5, 2013JOHNNY Depp wants a home in Britain.The actor and his girlfriend Amber Heard are reportedly eying several palatial pads to temporarily call home while he is in the UK to shoot Disney musical, Into The Woods.Depp  was looking to rent a home in Surrey previously occupied by fellow A-list stars Brad Pitt and Angelina...

0 comments

Robin Thicke Has Spent $600k on Cannabis

Robin Thicke Has Spent $600k on Cannabis

Posted by Adam Monday August 5, 2013ROBIN Thicke has opened up about his penchant for marijuana.The singer opened up about his love of the drug and claims he has spent a small fortune on cannabis — also known as weed – over the years.“I do smoke; I do everything I’m not supposed to do. Weed is my crutch, my muse,...

0 comments

Miley Cyrus Talks Being a Household Name!

Miley Cyrus Talks Being a Household Name!

Posted by Adam Monday August 5, 2013MILEY Cyrus loves being a household name!The actress, 20, says she considered dropping her surname — like Beyonce, Shakira or Ke$ha — but was worried it would affect the recognition she currently has.“I was thinking about dropping the Cyrus and just being Miley but there’s something powerful about the fact that my name now...

0 comments

Swaziland: Court Confirms New Rights for Women

Robert Pattinson and Sia Aren’t Dating!

Posted by Adam Monday August 5, 2013ROBERT Pattinson isn’t dating Sia!Aussie singer Sia has hit back at reports she’s being romanced by the hunky Twilight star.The rumor mill went into overdrive after they were spotted attending a Jay Z and Justin Timberlake concert in Pasadena, California last Sunday before heading out for drinks together later that week.However, Sia has taken...

0 comments

Justin Bieber Behaves Himself at Party!

Justin Bieber Behaves Himself at Party!

Posted by Adam Monday August 5, 2013JUSTIN Bieber is starting to behave himself!The singer partied in the Hamptons in the early hours of Sunday, and seemed to be uncharacteristically on his best behavior, according to New York Post gossip column Page Six.Bieber arrived at Ben Grieff and David Marino’s Southampton EDM club South Pointe with a group of 14 and...

0 comments

Swaziland: Court Confirms New Rights for Women

Kristen Stewart Still Struggling to Move on From Robert Pattinson

Posted by Adam Monday August 5, 2013KRISTEN Stewart is still getting support from her friends following her split from Robert Pattinson.Kristen was spotted in Los Angeles with her assistant leaving the Camp X-Ray set, according to X17. The actress looked stressed and clearly tired from a long day at work on the army drama, and possibly from her personal struggles.“Her...

0 comments

Swaziland: Court Confirms New Rights for Women

Jay-Z Tried to Cheat on Beyonce With Rapper Liv?

Posted by Adam Monday August 5, 2013RAPPER Jay-Z allegedly tried to cheat on Beyonce.Former model and aspiring rapper Liv claims Jay tried to step out on his marriage with her.“I could have messed with Jay, but got respect for Bey,” she said.“We were on the same set of a commercial, see, I was sitting by myself, and he sat next...

0 comments

Justin Bieber Flirts With Female Fan

Justin Bieber Flirts With Female Fan

Posted by Adam Monday August 5, 2013JUSTIN Bieber was seen cozying up to a female fan in Brooklyn, New York on August 2.The singer — who has an on/off romance with Selena Gomez — got closer than usual to the fan, according to HollywoodLife.Roxana Morcillo says she she traveled all the way from Madrid, Spain to see Justin, and that...

0 comments

Ashlee Simpson Praises Her Son

Ashlee Simpson Praises Her Son

Posted by Adam Monday August 5, 2013ASHLEE Simpson says her son Bronx Mowgli is becoming a “smart, sweet and amazing” little boy.The former singer raises the 4½-year-old with ex husband Pete Wentz.“He’s always funny,” she said.“He keeps you on your toes and he’s got great stories and a great imagination. When I was doing Chicago, he said he was making...

0 comments

EFCC Arrests Fraudster Over N5m

EFCC Arrests Fraudster Over N5m

The Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) has arrested one one Wale Olaide (a.k.a Wale Dollar), who it said specialises in defrauding unsuspecting members of the public through fraudulent bank credit alerts. Olaide met his waterloo when he duped a bureau de change operator, one Abdulhamid Abubakar, of N5m. A statement from the EFCC head of media and publicity, Wilson Uwujaren,...

0 comments

Swaziland: Court Confirms New Rights for Women

Students Protest Teachers Molesting Students In School

Students of a popular public school in Nnebisi, Asaba, Delta State (name withheld) have petitioned the commissioner for Basic and Secondary Education, Professor Patrick Muoboghare, over the persistence of sexual activities among some of their teachers during school hours. In the petition titled: “Sex at random in our school”, signed by the senior prefects, Jackson Isieche and Mariam Okpara, a copy...

0 comments

Swaziland: Court Confirms New Rights for Women

Osun State Police probe attempted defilement of 4-yr-old girl

THE Osun State Commissioner of Police, Mrs Dorothy Gimba, has ordered an investigations into the case of attempted defilement of a four-year-old girl by one Lateef Olateju, a barber, at Yemoja area in Ido-Osun, Egbedore Local Government Area of the state. The commissioner also directed the family unit of the state Police command to ensure proper medical care for the victim,...

0 comments

Man ambushed and set on fire in Enugu

Man ambushed and set on fire in Enugu

The Enugu State Police Command said it has commenced investigations into the alleged ambush and murder of one Sunday Ugwoke at Akpa Edem in Nsukka Local Government Area of the state, Saturday. The state Police Pubic Relations Officer, Mr. Ebere Amaraizu, who made this known in Enugu, yesterday, said the command was determined to unravel the circumstances surrounding the murder of...

0 comments

Swaziland: Court Confirms New Rights for Women

Detroit’s bankruptcy: not a death, a re-imagining

Related PostsDetroit becomes largest American city to file for bankruptcyPost-bankruptcy filing: What's happening to Detroit?Detroit businessman Barden dies after long illnessKevyn Orr, bankruptcy expert, named Detroit emergency manager Detroit businesses fret over city's unpaid bills I love Detroit and I will never live there again. I will never live there again not so much because it’s Detroit, but because it’s...

0 comments

Swaziland: Court Confirms New Rights for Women

Two human heads discovered in Onitsha hotel

This is the popular hotel in Onitsha that was demolished by the Anambra State government last week after two human skulls were allegedly discovered inside. The hotel, called Upper Class Hotel, is located at 8 Old Market Road, Onitsha and is owned by business man, Mr Bonaventure Mokwe. The human skulls, a male and a female head, were discovered after the...

0 comments

MISA's vision is of a Southern African region in which the media enjoys freedom of expression, independent from political, economic and commercial interests, pluralism of views and options. Our vision is of a region where members of society, individually or collectively are free to express themselves through any media of their choice without hindrance of any kind. A region too, where access to information must be unhindered and where information is readily available.

MISA's Mision and Vision

MISA is a dynamic, member-driven regional organisation with national chapters coordinated by a professional secretariat which seeks - through media monitoring, training, capacity building, research and the distribution of information - to foster free, independent and diverse media throughout Southern Africa in the service of democracy and development as stated in the Windhoek Decleration and the African Charter on Broadcasting.